Bruno Sammartino: 171 matches and 1 other appearances = 130 singles matches (97-9-10, 91.5% win) + 34 tag matches (24-3-5, 88.9% win)
Tony Parisi: 153 matches = 62 singles matches (42-6-7, 87.5% win) + 90 tag matches (59-8-7, 88.1% win)
Smasher Sloan: 147 matches = 94 singles matches (32-40-10, 44.4% win) + 53 tag matches (13-30-1, 30.2% win)
Baron Mikel Scicluna: 142 matches = 95 singles matches (44-26-13, 62.9% win) + 41 tag matches (13-19-2, 40.6% win)
Arnold Skaaland: 138 matches and 1 other appearances = 113 singles matches (44-39-9, 53% win) + 21 tag matches (11-8-1, 57.9% win)
Curtis Iaukea: 118 matches = 61 singles matches (27-24-4, 52.9% win) + 41 tag matches (7-24-4, 22.6% win)
Angelo Savoldi: 111 matches = 96 singles matches (21-59-6, 26.3% win) + 12 tag matches (0-12-0, 0% win)
Johnny Valentine: 105 matches = 70 singles matches (42-7-11, 85.7% win) + 35 tag matches (23-4-1, 85.2% win)
Bill Miller: 94 matches = 62 singles matches (20-19-10, 51.3% win) + 30 tag matches (5-19-3, 20.8% win)
Ricky Sexton: 84 matches = 69 singles matches (15-35-6, 30% win) + 12 tag matches (4-5-1, 44.4% win)
Miguel Perez: 74 matches = 59 singles matches (33-13-6, 71.7% win) + 12 tag matches (6-4-0, 60% win)
Argentina Apollo: 72 matches = 40 singles matches (27-1-2, 96.4% win) + 32 tag matches (16-6-2, 72.7% win)
Pete Sanchez: 69 matches = 55 singles matches (13-35-1, 27.1% win) + 6 tag matches (4-2-0, 66.7% win)
Louis Cerdan: 67 matches = 60 singles matches (35-15-3, 70% win) + 6 tag matches (2-2-0, 50% win)
Ronnie Etchison: 62 matches = 58 singles matches (11-40-3, 21.6% win) + 4 tag matches (0-4-0, 0% win)
Beast: 51 matches = 31 singles matches (13-10-2, 56.5% win) + 20 tag matches (2-15-1, 11.8% win)
Johnny Rodz: 49 matches = 44 singles matches (10-31-1, 24.4% win) + 4 tag matches (0-4-0, 0% win)
Bulldog Brower: 48 matches = 44 singles matches (28-7-2, 80% win) + 2 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Chief Big Heart: 46 matches = 43 singles matches (16-22-1, 42.1% win) + 3 tag matches (2-1-0, 66.7% win)
Tomas Marin: 46 matches = 38 singles matches (4-33-0, 10.8% win) + 4 tag matches (0-4-0, 0% win)
Tony Nero: 36 matches = 36 singles matches (7-23-1, 23.3% win)
Waldo Von Erich: 36 matches = 30 singles matches (18-8-1, 69.2% win) + 4 tag matches (2-0-0, 100% win)
Frank Hickey: 34 matches = 32 singles matches (0-30-0, 0% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Bull Ortega: 25 matches = 13 singles matches (4-3-2, 57.1% win) + 12 tag matches (1-5-3, 16.7% win)
Bobo Brazil: 25 matches = 21 singles matches (11-1-6, 91.7% win) + 4 tag matches (3-1-0, 75% win)
Domingo Robles: 24 matches = 20 singles matches (1-16-0, 5.9% win)
Tank Morgan: 24 matches = 14 singles matches (6-3-1, 66.7% win) + 10 tag matches (1-3-3, 25% win)
Hector Serrano: 23 matches = 16 singles matches (0-15-1, 0% win) + 3 tag matches (0-3-0, 0% win)
Jerry Graham: 23 matches = 14 singles matches (11-2-1, 84.6% win) + 9 tag matches (4-2-0, 66.7% win)
Tarzan Tyler: 21 matches = 17 singles matches (8-5-3, 61.5% win) + 4 tag matches (1-3-0, 25% win)
Sky Low Low: 16 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win) + 13 tag matches (0-11-0, 0% win)
Johnny Carr: 16 matches = 16 singles matches (1-14-0, 6.7% win)
Magnificent Maurice: 15 matches = 13 singles matches (3-8-1, 27.3% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Frank Durso: 15 matches = 14 singles matches (1-11-0, 8.3% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Mr Kleen: 15 matches = 15 singles matches (12-1-1, 92.3% win)
Jamaica Kid: 15 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win) + 13 tag matches (10-0-0, 100% win)
Little Beaver: 14 matches = 3 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win) + 10 tag matches (9-0-0, 100% win)
Arman Hussian: 13 matches = 11 singles matches (3-0-2, 100% win) + 2 tag matches (2-0-0, 100% win)
Gene Dubuque: 13 matches = 10 singles matches (2-8-0, 20% win) + 2 tag matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Ed Valentino: 12 matches = 11 singles matches (2-7-1, 22.2% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Sonny Myers: 12 matches = 12 singles matches (6-2-2, 75% win)
Little Brutus: 11 matches = 11 tag matches (0-8-0, 0% win)
Tony Altimore: 11 matches = 7 singles matches (0-5-0, 0% win) + 4 tag matches (1-3-0, 25% win)
Chuck Richards: 10 matches = 8 singles matches (0-7-1, 0% win)
Luke Graham: 9 matches = 9 singles matches (5-0-0, 100% win)
Ted Lewin: 9 matches = 7 singles matches (1-6-0, 14.3% win) + 1 tag matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Jack Ostermiller: 9 matches = 7 singles matches (1-6-0, 14.3% win)
Ernie Lassiter: 9 matches = 9 singles matches (7-0-1, 100% win)
Spiros Arion: 9 matches = 7 singles matches (4-0-0, 100% win) + 1 tag matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Roberto Gonzalez: 9 matches = 9 singles matches (0-8-0, 0% win)
Capt Lou Albano: 8 matches = 8 singles matches (0-2-1, 0% win)
Irish Jackie: 8 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win) + 6 tag matches (2-2-0, 50% win)
Fabulous Moolah: 7 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win) + 5 tag matches (5-0-0, 100% win)
Fuzzy Cupid: 7 matches = 2 singles matches (0-0-0,  + 5 tag matches (0-5-0, 0% win)
Frank Martinez: 6 matches = 3 singles matches (0-3-0, 0% win)
Sonny Boy Cassidy: 5 matches = 5 tag matches (4-0-0, 100% win)
Vera Kadar: 5 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win) + 4 tag matches (1-2-0, 33.3% win)
Dan Miller: 5 matches = 5 tag matches (0-4-0, 0% win)
Steve Stanlee: 5 matches = 4 singles matches (0-4-0, 0% win)
Billy the Kid: 4 matches = 4 tag matches (1-3-0, 25% win)
Darling Dagmar: 4 matches = 4 tag matches (3-0-0, 100% win)
Judy Grable: 4 matches = 4 tag matches (3-1-0, 75% win)
Donna Christanello: 4 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win) + 3 tag matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Cowboy Bradley: 4 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win) + 3 tag matches (3-0-0, 100% win)
Toni Rose: 4 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win) + 3 tag matches (2-0-0, 100% win)
Diamond Lil: 4 matches = 4 tag matches (0-3-0, 0% win)
Mike Loren: 4 matches = 4 singles matches (0-3-0, 0% win)
Luis Garcia: 4 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Joe Millich: 3 matches = 3 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Tony Galento: 3 other appearances
Charlie Robinson: 3 matches = 3 singles matches (2-1-0, 66.7% win)
unknown: 3 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win) + 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Joe Carr: 3 matches = 3 singles matches (1-2-0, 33.3% win)
Johnny DeFazio: 3 matches = 2 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Bobby Davis: 2 matches and 1 other appearances = 2 tag matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Jay Flores: 2 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Barbara Galento: 2 matches = 2 tag matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Umberto Mercado: 2 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Pedro Rodriguez: 2 matches = 2 singles matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Fred Valentine: 2 matches = 2 singles matches (1-1-0, 50% win)
Dorothy Patterson: 2 matches = 2 tag matches (0-2-0, 0% win)
Bette Boucher: 2 matches = 2 tag matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Sheik: 2 matches = 2 singles matches (2-0-0, 100% win)
Jose Garcia: 1 matches
Clark: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Tiny Roe: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Dick Turner: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Chris Scardino: 1 matches
Vito Gonzalez: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Frank Mickoy: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Princess Little Cloud: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Pancho Lopez: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Princess White Dove: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-0-0,
Diana Lynn: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Brenda Reed: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Bob Nandor: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Don McClarity: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-0-0,
Mongolian Stomper: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-0-0,
El Toro: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win)
Humberto Macardo: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Green Hornet: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Linda Carroll: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-0-0,
Hurricane Hunt: 1 matches
Geeto Mongol: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Bearcat Wright: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-0-1,
Tony Marino: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-0-0,
Chief White Owl: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Pat Lydia: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Bonita Little Cloud: 1 matches = 1 tag matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Joe Abby: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Sicilian Beast: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Don Serrano: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Wahoo McDaniel: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-0-0,
Ivan Koloff: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (0-1-0, 0% win)
Ace Freeman: 1 matches
Jack Davis: 1 matches = 1 singles matches (1-0-0, 100% win)